The Sea Has No Bottom: 15 Voices on Security

33 minute read

Published:

A Monet-style painting: on the open sea, a man stands at the bow of a small boat with no anchor, holding up a lantern, and a fleet of small boats follows him toward a far horizon with no shore in sight.

Author: Koutian Wu; GitHub: ktwu01

Some people spend their whole lives looking for security. A stable job, a stable life, a family, children. Then they lose the job, or the lover, or someone they love dies, or they hit a gap year, and it feels like losing their life. This kind of security is a false premise. Rulers created it to control people. Zoom out. People drift through time, and the Earth drifts through the universe. What is stable? Not even a server room. Your agent’s run gets killed by this process or that one. Even the biggest, greatest companies cannot last very long. Even the greatest nations in the world last only a few hundred years. So what chance does one person have? How do you find an anchor? You can’t. Anyone desperately searching for an anchor has the mindset of a drowning man. Only a drowning man needs an anchor. But if you can give others an anchor, you are a leader. Leaders are not necessarily smarter. Their edge is that their beliefs are firm. A firm belief means one of two things: either they are stupid, or they have thought deeply about the world, deeply enough to give others an anchor and a sense of security and lead everyone in one direction.

Having written that, I wanted to know how 15 other people would write it.

Yu Qiuyu

I once stood through a dusk at the edge of Lop Nur. Under my feet was Loulan.

The wind was strong, and the sand stung my face in small, fine points. Before me were a few collapsed earthen walls and the stumps of dead poplars, leaning in the sand like a crowd of people who had died standing up.

The people of Loulan must have believed the Kongque River would flow forever. They built walls, planted poplars, dug canals, married and raised children, and lived their days as if days were permanent. Camel caravans passed through, bringing silk and bronze mirrors, carrying away grapes and jade. Who then could have imagined the river would change course? It did, and a city was quietly closed over by sand, without leaving so much as a sigh.

The Chinese have always cherished the character 安, an, peace and safety. From the day it was made, it has been a woman under a roof: a house, a family, and so, safety. We say live in peace and work in contentment. We say cling to your native soil. We say while your parents live, do not travel far. Thousands of years of farming nailed us to the land. The land gave us grain, and it gave us a deep fear: to leave the land is to become a vagrant, to fall into the water.

But roofs collapse, rivers change course, and a dynasty lasts a few hundred years. Of the high Tang in Chang’an, all that remains are a few lonely pagodas, standing silent in the dusk of the Guanzhong plain.

Those who truly went far carried no anchor. When Xuanzang left the Jade Gate, behind him was an imperial ban, and ahead were eight hundred li of the Mokhaiyan desert. His waterskin spilled. For four nights and five days he drank nothing and fell in the sand. In his heart there was only a direction: the West.

Strangely, this man who refused an anchor became the anchor for countless monks over a thousand years. They walked west in his footprints and never felt they were drifting.

I think the anchor of a civilization was never driven into the land. It is driven into the footprints of those who dared to go without one.

Og Mandino

The Seventh Scroll

From this day forward, I will no longer search for an anchor.

I was once like a drowning man, grasping in dark water. I seized a job and believed it was the shore. I seized a person and believed he was the shore. I seized a city and believed it was the shore. But jobs leave, people leave, and cities are buried by sand. What I held in my hand was only ever water.

I have seen the truth. Rivers do not stop. Stars do not stop. The Earth itself wanders through the boundless night. The strongest walls will crumble. The greatest kingdoms last a few hundred springs and autumns. Even the sleepless machine is quietly put out in the dead of night. All things drift. By what right do I demand to stand still?

So I will no longer search for an anchor. I am the anchor.

The grain of wheat does not search for soil. It falls, and there it takes root. The eagle does not search for the wind. It spreads its wings, and the wind lifts it. I will no longer beg the world for a place that does not move. I will raise a post within my own heart.

When the storm comes, others will look about in panic, and I will stand firm. I do not know when the storm will end. I only know where I am going.

Those struggling in the water will see me. They will swim to me and take my hand. I will not push them away. I will show them the direction and lead them forward with me.

This is the secret of the leader: he is not necessarily wiser than others. He is only firmer.

I will no longer search for an anchor. I am the anchor.

I will read this scroll each morning until it is written in my blood, until I no longer tremble in the storm.

Socrates

Young man: Socrates, I lost my job. It feels like I lost my life.

Socrates: Did you lose your job, or your life?

Young man: My job. But my job gave me security.

Socrates: Is that security in the job, or in you?

Young man: In what the job gave me. Money, a title, knowing where to go every morning.

Socrates: Suppose the company were still there tomorrow, but you knew for certain it would fail in three years. Would you still feel secure?

Young man: No.

Socrates: Then what reassured you was never the job itself. It was the thought, “this will not end.” What you lost is a thought.

Young man: You could put it that way.

Socrates: Then what in the world does not end?

Young man: A nation? A few hundred years. The Earth? It drifts too. Even the machines we build get switched off.

Socrates: A man who spends his whole life searching for something that does not exist: what should we call him?

Young man: A pitiful man.

Socrates: Or simply a mortal. Now tell me: those who step forward and say, “Follow me, I know the way,” have they found this thing?

Young man: Probably not.

Socrates: Then what are they handing to others?

Young man: Something they do not have themselves.

Socrates: Do they know they do not have it?

Young man: The wise ones know. The foolish ones do not.

Socrates: And from the outside, can you tell the wise from the foolish?

Young man: No. Their eyes are equally firm.

Socrates: Then the one who knows he has nothing, and hands it over anyway: is he a fraud, or braver than we are?

Young man: I don’t know.

Socrates: Good. We began at “I lost my life” and arrived at “I don’t know.” That is progress.

Plato

Imagine a cave. A group of prisoners have been chained there since childhood, bound at the neck and leg so they can only face the wall. Behind them and above, a fire burns. Between the fire and the prisoners, people walk past carrying all kinds of objects, and the objects cast shadows on the wall.

All their lives the prisoners see only these shadows. The shadows appear each day in the same order. The prisoners name them and compete to guess which shadow comes next, and the best guesser is honored. They feel very safe. The wall is the world.

Heraclitus said no man steps into the same river twice. He was right: everything visible flows. Jobs, cities, bodies, shadows on a wall. When your author says no anchor can be found, he stands with Heraclitus.

But I say there is an anchor.

One prisoner breaks free. He turns and sees the fire, and his eyes burn. Someone drags him up the steep path and out of the cave. For the first time he sees the sun. His eyes stream with tears, and for a long time he can see nothing. Slowly he makes out reflections in water, then trees and mountains, and at last he can look at the sun itself. He understands: the things on the wall waver and go out, and only the eternal Forms under the sun are real. The Good, Justice, Beauty do not change course with the river.

So the anchor is outside the cave.

The story is not over. The one who has seen the sun must go back down into the cave. His eyes no longer know the dark. He stumbles, and he guesses shadows worse than anyone. He tells the prisoners the wall is false, and they do not understand. They laugh at him and say the trip up ruined his eyes. If they could lay hands on him, they would kill him.

That is how my teacher died. The Athenians gave him a cup of hemlock, and he drank it.

So I say the best rulers are those who do not want to rule. They would rather stay in the sunlight, and still they walk back into the cave. Because he does not want to rule, he is fit to rule.

Marcus Aurelius

(Written in camp on the Danube front)

1. At dawn, when you do not want to get up, tell yourself: I am rising to do the work of a human being. This is what I was born for. Why complain? Was I made to lie under the blankets and keep warm?

2. You are the emperor of Rome. The legions, the provinces, the Senate, tens of millions of people treat you as their anchor. Remember that Alexander of Macedon and his mule driver, once dead, came to the same dust.

3. Think of the time of Vespasian. People marrying, raising children, falling sick, dying, fighting, feasting, trading, farming, flattering, boasting, suspecting, plotting, wishing others dead, grumbling at their lot. That whole generation’s life is gone without a trace. Think of the time of Trajan. The same.

4. Asia and Europe are corners of the universe. The whole sea is a drop. Mount Athos is a clod of earth. This present moment is a point in eternity.

5. Soon you will forget everything, and soon everything will forget you.

6. People look for a retreat: the country, the seashore, the mountains. You have wanted that too. But whenever you choose, you can retreat into yourself. No place is quieter than your own soul. A mind free of passion is a citadel, and a person has no stronger refuge.

7. So the anchors outside will break. Build a fortress within.

8. And then what? Get up tomorrow morning as always and do the work of a human being. When others need you to stand firm, stand firm. That the ground beneath you is empty is your own business. There is no need to tell the soldiers.

Zhuangzi

Master Dongguo lost his office. He went home and wept, and for three days he did not eat. Zhuangzi passed by.

“Why do you weep?”

“I have lost what I leaned on.”

Zhuangzi said, “What you leaned on was your office? Your office leaned on the lord. The lord leaned on the state. The state leaned on all under heaven. And what does all under heaven lean on?”

Master Dongguo could not answer.

Zhuangzi said, “There were two boats on the sea. The first feared drifting, so it was tied to a post. The tide came, the post was torn out, and the boat capsized. The second was not tied. When the tide came, it rose with the tide. When the tide went, it fell with the tide. It floated about all day and never capsized.”

Master Dongguo said, “Then where does the untied boat finally go?”

Zhuangzi said, “That you must know where it goes is the reason you weep.”

A while later, a man holding a banner stood on the shore and cried to the crowd, “Follow me and be safe!” The crowd rushed to him, shoulder to shoulder, each afraid of being last.

Master Dongguo said, “His faith is so firm. Is he a sage?”

Zhuangzi laughed. “He is a boat too. The crowd is tied to him, and he is tied to the crowd. One post, nothing more. What sage is there in that? Besides, steal a belt buckle and you are executed. Steal a state and you become a lord. What they call safety is how the lords herd their people.”

Master Dongguo was silent a long time. Then he said, “So what should I do?”

Zhuangzi said, “The clever toil and the wise worry. The one with no talents seeks nothing. He eats his fill and wanders, drifting like an untied boat.”

Master Dongguo got up, ate, walked out the door, and no one knew where he went.

Lu Xun

The Chinese sense of security is, by and large, made of iron. The iron rice bowl. The iron house.

When the bowl breaks, a man wails to heaven as though he has lost his life, and the relatives and neighbors sigh along with him: what will become of this child now? Shut in the iron house, though, he sleeps very soundly, and no one feels short of breath.

My friend Jin Xinyi once came to urge me to write something. I said: imagine an iron house without a single window, virtually indestructible, with many people fast asleep inside who will soon suffocate. They will pass from sleep into death without feeling the pain of dying. Now if you cry out and wake a few of the lighter sleepers, so that these unfortunate few suffer the agony of an inescapable death, do you think you are doing them a kindness?

This is the leader’s difficulty. He wakes people and cannot give them a door.

Besides, the Chinese have another kind of anchor, invented by Ah Q. When someone beats him, he says, “It’s like a son beating his father,” and walks away satisfied. He loses his job, his woman, everything, and he can still drive a post into his heart, firmer than anyone’s. The anchor is fake, but he clings to it with all his strength, right up until they drag him off to be shot, still wishing he could draw his circle a little rounder.

I have never hesitated to judge with the worst intentions those who raise their arms and call out to the crowd. I have seen many people of firm belief. Some later became officials. Some became the guards of the iron house. Some became new Ah Qs, leading a crowd of little Ah Qs in chanting slogans.

And yet, since a few have woken, you cannot say there is no hope of destroying the iron house.

As for an anchor, it cannot be said to exist, nor can it be said not to exist. It is like a road across the earth. There was no road at first, but when many people walk the same way, a road appears.

Wang Xiaobo

When I was sent down to the countryside, I fed pigs. A pig’s life is set in advance: eat, sleep, put on weight, take the knife at year’s end. They have a great deal of security. Meals arrive on time, they never lose their jobs, and I never saw a pig fret over a gap year.

One pig was different. It was as lean as a goat and could jump onto the roof of the pigsty. It could also imitate a steam whistle. When it blew, the workers thought it was the quitting whistle and all went home. This reached the leadership. The leadership said it was sabotaging spring plowing and must be subjected to the dictatorship of the proletariat. The political instructor led twenty-odd men with pistols and shotguns and surrounded it. It did not panic. It picked a gap in the circle, shot through, and was gone.

I am forty now, and apart from this pig I have never seen anyone dare to ignore the settings of life like that. On the other hand, I have seen many people who want to set other people’s lives, and many who live contentedly inside the settings.

This post opens by saying that rulers created security to control people. That gives rulers too much credit. In my observation they are not that clever and do not have that many schemes. They just like setting things: when to start work, when to hold meetings, what age to marry, what age to have a child. And most people happen to like being set. Once you are set, you do not have to think, and not thinking feels very safe. The two sides click together, and nobody is fooling anybody.

As for leaders, I saw plenty in the countryside. Their beliefs were all very firm, and their voices were very loud at meetings. But if you ask who ever gave me a sense of security, I keep coming back to that pig. It taught me that walls can be jumped.

Nietzsche

When Zarathustra was thirty, he left his home and went into the mountains, and lived there ten years. One morning he rose with the dawn, came down, walked into the marketplace, and found the crowd quarreling over a wooden post. Everyone wanted to tie his boat to it.

He said to them: Are you looking for an anchor? I tell you, the sea has no bottom.

Man is a rope, tied between beast and overman, a rope over an abyss. Dangerous to cross, dangerous to stop halfway, dangerous to look back. And you want to drive a post into the middle of the rope and build a house on it.

Behold, I show you the last man.

“What is love? What is creation? What is longing? What is a star?” So asks the last man, and blinks.

“I have a tenured post, I have a house, I have children. We have invented stability,” says the last man, and blinks.

What the last man fears most is a gap year. He would rather live a hundred years in a room without air than stand one morning in the wind.

But I love those who go under. I love those who lost their jobs, their lovers, everything they leaned on, and did not go looking for the next post. They are a bridge, not a destination.

The crowd shouted: Zarathustra, give us this last man! No, Zarathustra, give us an anchor instead! We will follow you!

Zarathustra was silent a long while, and then he said:

You had not yet found yourselves, and you found me. So do all believers, and that is why all belief is so cheap.

Now I bid you lose me and find yourselves. Only when you have all denied me will I return to you.

One must still have chaos in oneself to give birth to a dancing star. Do not ask me for an anchor. Go and give birth to your stars.

Milan Kundera

1.

On the day Jan lost his job, he counted on the way home what he had left: an apartment still under mortgage, a wife who did not talk much, a daughter he drove to piano lessons on weekends. He found that, added together, these things were very heavy. He had always believed that heavy meant stable.

2.

People always confuse weight with safety. Parmenides divided the world into pairs of opposites: light and darkness, warmth and cold, being and non-being, lightness and weight. He held that lightness was positive and weight negative. We need not agree with him. But what Jan felt at that moment was this: once a piece of the weight is pulled out, what remains does not get lighter. It begins to tilt.

3.

An agent was running on his server. That afternoon another process killed it. He stared at the word Killed in the log and suddenly felt it was more honest than he was. It had never assumed it would run forever.

4.

What happens only once might as well not have happened at all. The Germans say: Einmal ist keinmal. Jobs, marriages, nations are all devices invented to resist this “only once.” They promise repetition. They promise that tomorrow will be like today. They promise to stamp your present life with a permanent seal.

5.

So someone steps forward and says: follow me, I know the way. The crowd sees the unwavering light in his eyes and breathes out. What is that light? It may come from having thought everything through. It may come from never having thought at all. To the crowd, the two lights look exactly the same.

6.

This is where kitsch begins. Kitsch makes two tears flow in quick succession. The first tear says: look, we have a direction, how nice. The second tear says: how nice to be moved, together with all mankind, by having a direction. It is the second tear that makes kitsch kitsch.

This is how the Grand March begins. The crowd moves forward and no one looks back, because whoever looks back will be called a traitor.

7.

Jan followed no one. He stood on his balcony until late, and for the first time felt an unbearable lightness. He could not tell whether it was freedom or falling.

Neither can the novelist. The novelist’s job is not to answer. He only leaves the question standing, and it stands longer than any anchor.

Nassim Nicholas Taleb

Start with two brothers. John worked in the HR department of a big bank for twenty-five years. His salary landed on the first of every month, with a bonus at year end, a pension, paid vacation. George drove a taxi in London. Some months he made a lot, some months not even enough for fuel, and every morning he had no idea how many fares he would get.

Everyone thought John was safer.

Then the bank had layoffs. John was fifty and could do nothing but fill in forms and sit in meetings. Overnight his income went from a number to zero. And George? George drove that month as usual, good days and bad. He had lived through a small unemployment every day of his life and was long used to it.

John’s stability was fake. All his volatility was pressed into one place, saved up for the day it blew up all at once. George’s instability was the real stability.

Next, a turkey. The butcher feeds it for a thousand days. With every day it is fed, the turkey grows more certain: humans love me, the world is safe, tomorrow will be like today. Its confidence peaks on day one thousand. Then comes the Wednesday before Thanksgiving.

Your stable job, your stable marriage, your stable nation: those are the turkey’s thousand days.

I grew up in Lebanon. Beirut was once called the Switzerland of the Middle East. For more than a thousand years its religions lived side by side, and the grown-ups said a war would last a few days at most. It lasted more than fifteen years. Since then I have known that the main use of the word “stability” is to give people a good night’s sleep before the disaster.

So stop looking for an anchor. Anchors make you fragile. Wind extinguishes a candle and energizes a fire. Be the fire. Learn to gain from shocks. Put ninety percent of what you have somewhere extremely safe, take the other ten percent and make the wildest bets you can, and do not touch the “seemingly safe” middle at all. That is the barbell.

As for leaders, I ask one question: does he have skin in the game? Don’t tell me what you believe. Tell me what is in your portfolio. A man of firm belief who never pays for his beliefs is what I call an intellectual yet idiot. Ancient commanders rode at the front of the charge. The Code of Hammurabi said that if a house collapses and kills its owner, the builder shall be put to death. A leader may hand you an anchor. He must first tie himself to the same post.

1/ You think your job gives you security. A job is renting out your time. You will never get rich renting out your time, and you will never be safe either, because the lease can end at any moment.

2/ Desire is a contract you make with yourself to be unhappy until you get what you want. Security is a contract too: you agree to be anxious until you find an anchor. You have been signing it your whole life.

3/ Seek wealth, not money or status. Wealth is assets that earn while you sleep. Status is a zero-sum game: someone goes up, someone goes down. Hold on to status as an anchor and you will have to watch other people forever.

4/ Find your specific knowledge. It cannot be trained, because it comes from your curiosity, your history, the obsessions other people find strange. If society can train you, it can train someone else to replace you. Any position that can be replaced is dangerous, however stable it looks.

5/ Use leverage. The old leverage was labor and capital, and it needed permission. The new leverage is code and media, and it needs no one’s permission. Your code, your agents, your writing work for you while you sleep. If a process gets killed, start another one.

6/ Productize yourself.

7/ Escape competition through authenticity. No one can compete with you on being you. It is the one position no one can take from you, and the only thing that deserves to be called an anchor.

8/ Play long-term games with long-term people. All returns in life, whether in wealth, relationships, or knowledge, come from compound interest.

9/ Leaders look firm mostly because they have figured out what they want and what they do not want. Most people’s anxiety comes from wanting too much, from signing too many contracts at once.

10/ Happiness is a choice, and a skill. Peace is happiness at rest. A peaceful person at sea does not feel adrift, because he never planned to reach the shore.

Ray Dalio

Let me start with the most painful failure of my life.

In 1982, I was absolutely certain the US economy was heading into a depression. I testified before Congress, went on television, and bet on it publicly. My conviction could not have been firmer.

I was wrong. The stock market began a bull run that lasted decades. My firm lost almost everything. My employees left one by one until it was just me. I had to borrow four thousand dollars from my dad to pay my family’s bills.

That failure changed my life. I went from “I’m right” to “How do I know I’m right?”

So when someone says a leader’s edge is firm belief, I say: firmness is dangerous. I have seen too many smart people killed by certainty, including me in 1982. What a real leader does is find the smartest people most likely to disagree with him and let them challenge him as sharply as they can. I call it radical transparency and believability weighting.

On security: I studied the rise and fall of great powers over the last five hundred years. The Dutch, the British, the Americans, and the dynasties of China. The pattern is clear. From rise to decline, an empire runs about two hundred and fifty years. Debt cycles, internal conflict between rich and poor, external rising powers, repeating round after round. Your author says even the greatest nations last only a few hundred years. The data backs him up.

But there is good news in this. If everything changes, then change itself has patterns. The world is a machine. The economy is a machine. Your life is a machine too. Machines break, but you can understand how they work and prepare before they break.

That is where I found my anchor: in principles. A principle is the consistent way you handle the same kind of situation. Circumstances change, companies fail, you lose your job, but principles travel with you.

One of my principles: Pain plus Reflection equals Progress.

Losing a job hurts. Losing a lover hurts. Losing family hurts. Don’t run from it. Sit down and ask yourself: what did I learn from this? What will I do next time? Then write the answer down.

Do that and you have turned one pain into one principle. Collect enough principles and you no longer need an anchor, because you know what to do when the next storm comes. By then, others will come to ask you.

Albert Camus

There is only one really serious philosophical question: after you lose your job, do you still get up tomorrow morning?

The rest, whether the world has three dimensions, whether the mind has nine or twelve categories, whether the company will go public next year, comes afterward.

Where does the absurd come from? From the confrontation between man and the world. Man calls out again and again for an explanation, a guarantee, something that will not break. The world says nothing. The absurd is born of this confrontation between the human need and the unreasonable silence of the world.

The man who just lost his job stands at the subway entrance and watches the crowd part around him and close again. His badge still hangs from his neck. He forgot to take it off. For the first time he notices that the track of getting up, commuting, clocking in, meetings, lunch, commuting, sleep can break. Once the track breaks, “why” rises up.

The gods condemned Sisyphus to roll a boulder to the top of a mountain, where it would roll back down, and he would push it up again. There is no more dreadful punishment than futile and hopeless labor. He has no anchor and no end.

But what interests me most is the moment he walks back down. He watches the boulder roll away, turns, and with a heavy, even step walks toward a torment that will never end. In that moment he is stronger than his rock. The gods can do nothing to him.

The struggle itself toward the heights is enough to fill a man’s heart. One must imagine Sisyphus happy.

In the depths of winter, I finally learned that within me there lay an invincible summer.

Kahlil Gibran

Then a man who had just lost his work said, Speak to us of Security.

And he answered:

Your security is a house that fear has built for itself.

The thicker you build the walls, the less you hear the wind; yet the wind does not stop because you cannot hear it.

Your work is not your work. It only borrows your hands to complete its own season. When the season passes, it leaves, as autumn leaves a tree. And the tree does not die.

Your loved ones and your kin are not yours. They are like water passing through a riverbed. The riverbed takes its shape from them, yet the riverbed has never owned the water.

You say the empty window between seasons is to be feared. Yet only when the window is empty can the light come in.

By day you count your possessions, and by night you count your fears, and the two ledgers always add up to the same sum.

There will be one among you who stands at the bow and says he sees the shore.

Call him not a prophet for this, nor call him a liar.

He has only, one step before you, admitted the sea.